Getting a review published
Nothing written on Client Candor goes straight to the page. Each new review waits as pending until a moderator has compared it with our review guidelines. Then it is either published or turned down, and only a published review shows on the company’s page or counts in its score.
The moderator asks four questions:
- Did it happen to the writer? It must come from someone who ordered, booked, visited or got a quote from that company.
- Is anything in it off limits? We cut links and phone numbers, anything personal about employees, threats and hate speech.
- Is it one person posting again and again? We check for that, and for reviews planted by the company’s employees or by its rivals.
- Is it too soon? A person gets one review per company every 30 days.
The company being reviewed gets one tool: a public reply. Editing, hiding or deleting a review is off the table, and so is paying to change how we handle one. A one-star review clears the same check as a five-star one, no harder and no easier.
How the score works
A company’s score is the plain average of the stars in its published reviews, rounded to one decimal place. We don’t estimate it, weight it for anyone who pays, or adjust it by hand.
At 5 published reviews, a score earns its band and color. Before that you still see the number, marked New, because a few reviews can swing it a long way.
| Band | Average | Looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Top-notch | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Solid | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Uneven | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Shaky | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Bad | under 2.0 | 1.6 |
Buying versus service
Each reviewer tells us whether they bought something, asked for a quote or hired the company for a service. Once enough people have answered, buying and service get separate scores. A company can sell well and service badly, or the other way around.
The finer points, and the price
Reviewers can also rate four details: straight talk, fair pricing, ease and timing, and quality. They can tell us whether they paid the price they were quoted and whether any fees caught them by surprise. None of this shows on a page until 5 customers have answered that question.
The ranking formula
Why not just sort by the score? Three perfect reviews would then outrank forty excellent ones.
So a list sorted by rating gives every company a head start of 5 imaginary reviews at 3.5 stars. Its real reviews then pull it toward its true average, more with each one:
ranking score = (5 × 3.5 + its stars, added up) ÷ (its review count + 5)
That formula only sets the order of lists. The score on a company’s page is always the plain average, nothing else.
How the two sides are chosen
Each company page opens with two of its own reviews next to each other, and the home page shows the same two as short quotes. Stars decide which two, and nothing else does:
- The best review is its highest-rated published review; if several tie, the newest wins. It only appears if it gives 4 or 5 stars.
- The most critical is its lowest-rated published review, again the newest on a tie. It only appears if it gives fewer than 5 stars and isn’t already the best review.
If no review fits, the page says so. We don’t swap in a different one.
Where each review comes from
Reviews reach us three ways, and most carry a line underneath saying which:
- Sent in by a customer, here on Client Candor. The customer wrote it on this site, start to finish.
- Sent in by a customer through the company's own feedback form. The company collected it from one of its own customers and forwarded it to us. If the company picked it out, edited it or paid for it, we turn it away.
- From other review sites. Posted by the customer somewhere else first; we show it as it appeared there. These carry no source line.
Where listings come from
We put each listing together ourselves. The four facts on it (name, address, phone number and website) are ones we collected and checked.
A business that shuts down, or one we can no longer verify, drops out of sight. We hide the listing instead of erasing it, and every review on it stays where it was.
Any company can claim its listing for free, to fix its details and answer customers. Claiming does nothing to the score.
Flagging a review
Each review carries a Report link. Use it when a review breaks our guidelines, names the wrong company, or looks fake to you. A moderator looks at every report and may take the review down, leave it up, or ask the reviewer for more detail. A reported review stays up while we look into it.