Chernice Lane B.
Reviewed
They selected a great contractor that…
They selected a great contractor that was honest and hardworker

31 reviews
Chosen by stars alone. Ties go to the newest.
The best review
“Dire emergency fixed on the next day.”
The service and help given by the representative when I called was a lot faster than expected. It was an emergency and they got the technician to my house the next day and it was fixed in 30 minutes. I'm thrilled and thankful for everyone who helped through this ordeal. Thank you so much.
The most critical
“Extremely Disappointing and…”
Extremely Disappointing and Unprofessional Experience I would strongly caution anyone considering doing business with Prestige Home Warranty. My experience with this company was extremely frustrating and unacceptable. After filing a claim, I was treated as though I had done something wrong and was actually accused…
Prestige Home Guard is a premier home warranty provider dedicated to offering reliable and comprehensive coverage for homeowners.
Every published review of Prestige Home Guard (prestigehomeguard.
NJRepair Service Providers

Grand Prairie, TXRepair Service Providers

Jackson, MIRepair Service Providers

Longwood, FLRepair Service Providers
31 published reviews, newest at the top
Chernice Lane B.
Reviewed
They selected a great contractor that was honest and hardworker
Leah R.
Reviewed
Extremely Disappointing and Unprofessional Experience I would strongly caution anyone considering doing business with Prestige Home Warranty. My experience with this company was extremely frustrating and unacceptable. After filing a claim, I was treated as though I had done something wrong and was actually accused of making a fraudulent claim. Rather than listening to my concerns and attempting to resolve the issue professionally, one of the managers, Allen, was extremely rude, disrespectful, and unprofessional. His manner of handling the situation was completely inappropriate for someone in a management position. What made the experience even worse was feeling as though I was being threatened with legal action simply because I questioned the handling of my claim. Customers should not be made to feel intimidated or treated like they are doing something wrong when they are simply trying to use a service they paid for. Based on my experience, I would not recommend Prestige Home Warranty to anyone. In my opinion, the way this company handled my claim was unacceptable and left me feeling that my money was wasted. By contrast, I have had a much better experience with American Home Shield. They actually listen to their customers, communicate professionally, and make you feel like they are trying to help rather than intimidate you. Save your money and think twice before choosing Prestige Home Warranty. I would not use this company again.
Prestige Home Guard repliedSep 17, 2026
We’re sorry that you were unhappy with your experience, but we believe some important context is missing from this review.
Jeffrey U.
Reviewed
The service and help given by the representative when I called was a lot faster than expected. It was an emergency and they got the technician to my house the next day and it was fixed in 30 minutes. I'm thrilled and thankful for everyone who helped through this ordeal. Thank you so much.
Richard B.
Reviewed
Prestige made the process fairly straightforward the part had to be ordered and was sent directly to my house. Once the part arrived within 24 hrs the technician was able to come and install the new part. Everything went very smoothly. The technician was excellent and completed the installation very quickly.
Albert M.
Reviewed
My hot water tank quit working on a Saturday. I called and filed a claim and was told I would hear something in 24 hours. Sunday, I hadn't heard anything and called again. Again, was told I would hear back in 24 hours. I told the AI assistant that I wanted to talk to a human being. I received a call from someone who said they were personally going to look into my claim. Monday, I called again and talked to someone who said they were having trouble finding a technician. They asked me for possible 3rd party people to come. I gave them two names. I received a call that someone would be at my home in a couple of hours. After the technicians determined I needed a new tank, I called Prestige and talked to Adam. He talked to the technicians and got the info on what needed to be done. Then he asked to speak to me. Adam told me to pay them $95. And he would submit a claim to get approval for a new tank. Which could take up to 24 hours. When the technicians were ready to leave, they presented me with a bill for $154.50. I explained my contract limited me to only paying $100 max. They said to take it up with the warranty company. When I called Adam to see what to do about the overage, he said that he told me to only pay $95. I said I explained that to the technicians and they said to take it up with the warranty company and since they were a third-party vendor I paid their bill. Adam refused to offer any solution as to the overage. At one point he said it was like I gave them a tip. I told him that it would be a shame to go to small claims court over $54.50. Adam said he wasn't suggesting I sue the vendor to get my money. I corrected him and told him I was talking about suing Prestige for not honoring their contract. Adam said that he told me to pay them only $95 on a recorded line. I told him I said the warranty company told me I would only have to pay $100 max for a service call. And the technician told me to take it up with the warranty company. And that there were three people who heard that conversation. Later Adam and I reached a compromise. But I let him know this experience left a bad taste in my mouth.
Emily
Reviewed
The best home warranty I ever had, Prestige Home Guard has been amazing to me , my repair was done very quickly.
Joanne
Reviewed
Adam listened to what my needs were.
Harold S.
Reviewed
Adam was very knowledgeable and helpful and excited about the company and the product. Very honest and forthright